Thursday, February 12, 2015

To be or not to be soliloquy

Hamlet's soliloquy from Act 3 Scene 1 is his own struggle over whether he should live or die. Throughout the soliloquy he lists out the the reasons behind each one. He states "and by a sleep we end the heartache and the thousand natural shocks that flesh is heir to" (III.i.69-71) and later "Who would fardels bear, to grunt and sweat under a weary life, but that the dread of something after death" (III.i.84-86). In these two quotes Hamlet the two sides of his indecision, that death will bring an end to all of his earthly suffering and anguish, but he is uncertain what lies beyond death, and what awaits him could be worse than what he is facing at the moment. The way in which Hamlet thinks through this decision further blurs the distinction between madness and sanity within Hamlet. The subject of what he is debating would make one think that he is mad, yet his systematic reasoning and use of logic to debate the two sides would suggest otherwise, and perhaps suggest that Hamlet is merely acting and is aware that people are watching him. Furthermore, Hamlet's contemplation characterizes him as someone who does not act on impulse. He is someone who thinks things through before doing something. He states "Thus conscience does make cowards of us all" (III.i.91), which leads me to believe that it will be Hamlet's own conscience that will make him unable to act and make a choice when the time comes, and he will face consequences because of it.

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Fate and Free Will

1) Free will is critical in determining our path, because it is essential to what is means to be human. Our ability to think and choose freely based on our own individual experiences and personalities is what sets one person apart from another. It is because of this that each person's own path is as individual as they are. For this reason, humans are in control of their own fate or path, we have the ability to stay the course or change it at any time.
2) If one looks back on their life, it may seem that the people in it are just "actors" playing out their "roles." This ones the best friend, the other the enemy, he is the husband, she is the sister, however this is looking at it in a very narrow and single-minded manner. Who is a friend to one is an enemy to another, or a spouse, co-worker, child etc. There are too many different perspectives of one single person to fit them in a specific "role." If the world was indeed a stage, it would be too dynamic to be understood. Even though people can't be fit into roles, this doesn't mean they don't pretend to be someone they're not. Nobody is ever fully honest, with others or even with themselves, at the same time, no one is ever pretending all the time.
3) Whether revenge or suicide is justifiable would depend on the situation. In a situation, what appears to be the right or wrong thing changes depending on the context and the person themselves. One's sense of justice also bends as events come to pass, and part of that is justifying the actions of themselves as well as others, including revenge and suicide.
4) Just as justice is subjective, so is "madness." For the most part, madness in a general sense is one's loss of mental control and grip on reality. Of course, the ability to define these things and know when someone has actually lost control is hard to determine. It is context that determines how each person defines madness, and each person will see it differently. Factors of context include, society, culture, specific situation, personal experience, and others.

Monday, December 1, 2014

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner by Samuel Taylor Colridge is a poem that tells of the disastrous journey of a sailor and the misfortune he brought upon himself and the crew due to the fact that he shot an albatross. The author’s purpose in writing this is to show that all actions, even the smallest of ones, can have dire consequences because all living things have value. The author portrays this through symbolism and irony.
                The major symbol in the poem is the albatross. It is a symbol of hope because it is leading the ship back north safely and provides the crew with companionship and joy. The mariner then shoots the albatross, thinking it unimportant, and unknowingly crushes hope and the chances of the ships safe guidance. The crew is upset about the mariner shooting the bird, but they don’t see much harm done it in, and therefore don’t understand the life that has been taken, and do not punish the mariner. By letting the mariner go they fail to avenge the bird and prove that they value all life, which makes them just as bad as the mariner who killed it. It is this act of ignorance that costs the crew their lives. For killing the bird, the mariner is given several punishments, however in between those punishments he is given false hope that things will get better, only for the next misfortune to arise. The storm subsides, only for bad weather to repair. The souls of the dead crew man appear to move on, only to come back and haunt the mariner again. This false hope is the befitting consequence for killing the bird, which was a symbol of hope. The mariner wasn’t able to understand the value of the bird’s existence until he had gone through all of the disastrous events.

                The author uses irony to illustrate how all life has value, and it shouldn’t be taken without purpose. For example, after winning the gamble with Death, Life-In-Death wins the ability to decide the fate of the crew. She kills the entire crew except for the mariner who killed the bird, and leaves the body and souls of the dead on the ship to torment the mariner. The punishment is ironic because one would expect Life-In-Death to kill the mariner because he is the one who committed the crime. However, her choice to not kill him is a befitting punishment because she is toying with the lives of the crew and killing them as easily as the mariner had killed the bird. By seeing this, the mariner is able to understand that in that moment he is just as cruel as Death, and that taking life carelessly has dire consequences, just as the deaths of the crew took a mental toll on the mariner. 

Monday, November 24, 2014

The Individual in Society Questions

1) Every human needs some sort of interaction or communication in order to stay sane. What median it comes through and the quantity is what differs from person to person. For example, when person might consider "isolation" living all alone in a cabin in the woods. Another might find the solitude peaceful and comforting. However that person is not truly in isolation, because they find and maintain a relationship with nature that allows them to think and interact in some form. It is complete isolation that humans react badly to, such as being chained up in a pitch black room with no escape, no windows or light, with no outlet for communication. This type of environment would cause one to descend into a sort of madness after some period of time, one cannot survive on one's thoughts alone.
2) Individuals need a connection to something in order to feel human. Whether it is art, music, religion, politics, etc. individuals need something or someone through which they can express their ideas, feelings, beliefs, talents, or skills. It is through these interactions and connections that one feels a part of something, yet also feels singular and individual. It is through this that one develops their identity, and it is identity that makes one feel human.
3) When we don't take responsibility for our actions the consequences affect us both individually and as a group. Not taking responsibility for one's actions can cause one to be isolated by others, and lost the important interactions that humans need. It also causes harm to other individuals. Furthermore, not taking responsibility causes a chain reaction of other people refusing to do it. This degrades society as a whole and causes humanity to lose its sense of justice and consequence.
4) A lack of compassion or understanding leads to prejudice and stereotyping because humans always have a tendency to fear the unknown. People are stubborn, and what they don't understand they tend to write off in ways that make themselves feel more secure. Certainty is what makes people feel secure, and by creating assumptions of people based on some sort of trait, people feel more secure in who they are and who others are, even if it is completely wrong and causes harm to others. Only through understanding can this be avoided, because through it that initial fear can be eliminated.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Twelfth Night Act 4 Response 2

In act 4 scene 2 of Shakespeare's Twelfth Night Feste disguises himself as Sir Tobas and "examines" Malvolio for madness. Through his examination however, he begins to convince Malvolio himself that he is mad. Malvolio states that he is being held in darkness, to which Feste replies "Why it hath bay windows transparent as barricadoes, and the clerestories toward the south-north are as lustrous as ebony; and yet complainest thou of obstruction"(IV.ii.38-41). This describes the room as light, yet Malvolio sees it as dark, which it is. Although after this Malvolio continues to state that he his not mad, there is most definitely growing doubt. If Malvolio was completely convinced of his sanity, he would have called Sir Tobas out as a fake or as deceiving. Yet he continues with the examination with all seriousness and desperately tries to convince Feste that he is sane. This seed of doubt causes Malvolio to actually go mad. This is known for sure later on when Feste reveals to Malvolio through changing of voice that he was Sir Tobas and that he was made into a fool. Yet Malvolio seems to not understand this, and becomes confused, and continues to seriously ask Feste for "some ink, paper, and light"(IV.ii.115-116) so that he can write to Olivia.

Thursday, November 13, 2014

Are Shakespear's Messages about Gender Roles Relevant Today?

In Shakespear's play Twelfth Night, each character seems to have their own expectations of their own and the opposite gender, but as certain characters genders are unclear to other characters, it causes confusion in the characters love and attraction to which person, and those expectations of genders are mixed up. Through this identity confusion, the author is stating the message that both genders put themselves and the opposite sex in certain gender roles that not only contradict themselves but are also proven wrong.
This message is still necessary today and applies to our modern world. For all the accomplishments that have been made in reaching gender equality and the eradication of gender roles and stereotypes, they are still present in our society. In Twelfth Night the character Orsino compares men's and women's magnitude for love and passion to an appetite, stating "Alas their love may be called appetite, no motion of the liver, but the palate, that suffer surfeit, cloyment, and revolt; but mine is all as hungry as the sea, and can digest as much," (II.IV.107-111), yet earlier he states "For, boy, however we do praise ourselves, our fancies are more giddy and unfirm, more longing, wavering, sooner lost than worn, than woman's are," (II.IV.37-40). In this quote Shakespeare is showing his message about gender roles and their contradictions because Orsino contradicts himself in his own views of men and women. He claims in the second quote that men's attractions are more likely to shift from person to person, yet in the first one he claims that men are more passionate in their love for a person that women are, and even praises his own passion which he so warned about earlier on. Through this contradiction Shakespeare shows how invalid gender roles and expectations are. This message can be applied today since gender roles are still very much prevalent. The video clip "Shakespeare Gender Swap" showed that people perceived the same character doing the same actions differently when the gender was switched, often more negatively for the girls. This difference in characterization shows that society still holds certain views of each gender.
Furthermore, in Twelfth Night Viola, who is masquerading as a man named Cesario, retaliates to Orsino's comments and states "We men may say more, sweat more, but indeed our shows are more than will; for still we prove much in our vows but little in our love," (II.V.128-130). Viola's retort shows that both men and women are guilty of making assumptions based on gender, and that stereotyping leads to more stereotyping. Orsino's expectations of women makes Viola give a negative expectation of men, however this makes her no better than Orsino. This is something that often happens today. When one gender stereotypes the other, the natural response is to do the same back. This is why feminists often get a bad rap, because people state that they are for women superiority instead of equality, which is true of some but not all. A better response to gender roles is to show how and prove through actions how they are untrue, instead of creating more to belittle the other group. This will lead to less stereotyping for both sides and better understanding between all.

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

Diving into the Wreck SPOTTTS

Subject: Confronting pasts and gaining understanding from them

Paraphrase: The diver puts on various gear for the dive. They are diving alone. There is a ladder. It is always there. People who have used it know its significance. Others just see it as another piece of equipment. The diver starts going down the ladder. They are still above water. They continue going down. They go slowly and are unsure of where the water starts. The diver sees blue than green than black as they go into the water, the mask is keeping them alive and they have to learn how to move about on their own. It's hard to stay focused on what the diver came for with so many things to see. The purpose of the dive was to explore a wreck. The diver is guided and driven by the words in the book of myths. They came to see the damage of the wreck and gain insight from it. The diver ignores smaller incidents looking for something big and significant. The diver wants to see exactly what happened in the incident and not what others have said about it. The diver watches the incident played out by a mermaid and a merman. The diver identifies as both parties in the incident, and can see how both have been damaged. In these incidents, there are no individuals, their names are lost and forgot, and the scene as a whole becomes the identity of the person.

Occasion: A person diving into their own past to look at a wreck. Also written in the seventies during the beginning of the feminism movement.

Title:"Diving into the wreck" It is significant because to gain understanding from a past event, one must completely submerge themselves into it and look at exactly what happened by all parties involved. The wreck signifies that there is damage and pain from the incident.

Tone: Insightful. The diver finds meaning in every aspect of the dive. From submersion to finding the damage, the diver gains somethings from what they observe. It shows the importance of the dive in its entirety to the diver and that they are willing and desperate to gain some sort of understanding to help themselves in some way.

Theme: The theme is the past, and how one will not be able to be able to move on from it until the actual even and its effects are fully understood.

Speaker: The speaker is the diver in first person narrative.