I agree with Yaeger’s criticism of The Awakening. Edna’s “freedom” and “independence” is only an
illusion. She believes that because she has escaped from the influence and
control of her husband Leonce, she has escaped from outside forces entirely.
The reality is, that she has just moved from one evil to a lesser one. Robert
is what controls her life, as opposed to Leonce. He is not present for most of
the book, yet he is the driving force for what Edna’s actions and is what
consumes most of her thoughts. In some ways Robert is similar to Leonce in his
view of women as possessions of their husbands, which is why he is ultimately
unable to commit to Edna and believes she is only being cruel in her pursuit of
him. Ultimately, Edna was not trying to liberate herself through her own
actions but through another man.
Yaeger’s
main argument is that Edna cannot truly liberate herself because she doesn’t
have her own voice. At the beginning of the book, Edna barely speaks, instead
keeping her thoughts within her own mind. When she does begin to speak, she is
only mimicking Robert’s speech. Yaeger writes “In the scene in The Awakening where Edna returns to the
beach from her unearthly swim, it is Robert Lebrun who speaks for her, who
frames and articulates the meaning of her adventure, and the plot her invents
involves a mystical, masculine sea-spirit responsible for Edna’s sense of
election, as if romance were the only form of elation a heroine might feel.”
Edna’s own speech and actions start to become more romantic and whimsical after
this, as well as her affixation on Robert. Her “awakening” did not come about
from her own strengths but from the influence of a man and her own desires for
him.
Edna doesn’t
realize until Robert returns that she has been mimicking his own voice. His
rejection of her makes her aware of his similarities to Leonce and that her own
inner voice doesn’t match up with his. She realizes that she is still like the
parrot at the beginning of the story, mimicking others speech and only speaking
another half-language that no one understands. Edna had risked everything to
liberate romantically but not totally and lost, which is why she is pushed to
her own demise.