Wednesday, October 29, 2014

Critical Response to The Awakening

I agree with Yaeger’s criticism of The Awakening. Edna’s “freedom” and “independence” is only an illusion. She believes that because she has escaped from the influence and control of her husband Leonce, she has escaped from outside forces entirely. The reality is, that she has just moved from one evil to a lesser one. Robert is what controls her life, as opposed to Leonce. He is not present for most of the book, yet he is the driving force for what Edna’s actions and is what consumes most of her thoughts. In some ways Robert is similar to Leonce in his view of women as possessions of their husbands, which is why he is ultimately unable to commit to Edna and believes she is only being cruel in her pursuit of him. Ultimately, Edna was not trying to liberate herself through her own actions but through another man.
            Yaeger’s main argument is that Edna cannot truly liberate herself because she doesn’t have her own voice. At the beginning of the book, Edna barely speaks, instead keeping her thoughts within her own mind. When she does begin to speak, she is only mimicking Robert’s speech. Yaeger writes “In the scene in The Awakening where Edna returns to the beach from her unearthly swim, it is Robert Lebrun who speaks for her, who frames and articulates the meaning of her adventure, and the plot her invents involves a mystical, masculine sea-spirit responsible for Edna’s sense of election, as if romance were the only form of elation a heroine might feel.” Edna’s own speech and actions start to become more romantic and whimsical after this, as well as her affixation on Robert. Her “awakening” did not come about from her own strengths but from the influence of a man and her own desires for him.

            Edna doesn’t realize until Robert returns that she has been mimicking his own voice. His rejection of her makes her aware of his similarities to Leonce and that her own inner voice doesn’t match up with his. She realizes that she is still like the parrot at the beginning of the story, mimicking others speech and only speaking another half-language that no one understands. Edna had risked everything to liberate romantically but not totally and lost, which is why she is pushed to her own demise.  

Monday, October 27, 2014

Awakening Dialectical Journal 31-End

“You seem to be forcing me into disclosures which can result in nothing; as if you would have me bare a wound for the pleasure of looking at it, without the intention or power of healing it.” (144).
Robert saying this is significant because it shows the miscommunication and the lack of comprehension between Edna and Robert. Robert has the same views as the average Creole man, where woman are possessions of their husbands. Because of this, Robert doesn’t believe that Edna is serious in her pursuit of him and that what she is doing is cruel to him and his feelings for her. Because of this, he will never be able to fully commit to the relationship and the two will never be together.
“A bird with a broken wing was beating the air above, reeling, fluttering, circling disabled down, down to the water.” (156).
Throughout the book, there have been many mentions of birds. They are symbolic of freedom and independence, which Edna is trying to gain. However what stops the bird, or Edna, from taking full flight is the chains of society. Edna sees the bird with the broken wing struggling to fly and realizes that her wings are also broken. There is something, maybe her children that will not let her be free. Rather than continue to struggle and fight, she decides to give up and succumb to the ocean.
“I’m not going to be forced into doing things… Nobody has the right- except children perhaps…” (150).
This quote seems to represent the author’s own views on a woman’s duty and her freedom. Throughout the book, the children have remained somewhere in Edna’s thoughts. They are never fully present, yet they are never full forgotten. The author’s purpose in this line is to show that the only thing that a woman has to do is take care of her children in some form. However, this should not limit her freedoms and independence, nor does it mean the husband can’t raise them either. Children are dependent, unlike husbands, and therefore need someone to take care of them.


Friday, October 24, 2014

Awakening Dialectical Journal 21-30

“’I hope it isn’t Arobin.’ He muttered to himself as he walked. ‘I hope to heaven it isn’t Arobin’”(95).
The author uses employs foreshadowing in this quote. She writes the doctor stating that he hopes a certain male character isn’t in Edna’s life to hint that she will later affiliate with that man. The author’s purpose in including this is to show that women, when given freedom, will not just become attached to every man that comes their way. Arobin does come into Edna’s life, and she does have a connection with him, but it is not to the extent that she is in love with Robert and she has control over their relationship.
“There was a dull pang of regret because it was not the kiss of love that had enflamed her, that it was not love which held this cup of life to her lips” (113).
This quote is an example of repetition. The words “it was not love” are repeated twice to emphasize what Edna’s feelings actually are toward Arobin. The author is hinting here that what she feels is not love, but lust. The author’s purpose in using this is to emphasize the fact that women are not emotional and moody creatures that constantly need guidance and fidelity to help them. Edna is faced with a difficult situation but she is able to pull apart and recognize her feelings and can accordingly decide on a course of action.
“The bird that would soar above the level plain of tradition and prejudice must have strong wings. It is a sad spectacle to see the weaklings bruised, exhausted, fluttering back to earth” (112).
The author uses metaphor here to compare Edna to a bird. A bird’s flight is often represented of freedom, which is exactly what Edna’s experiencing. She is ignoring all of the societal chains that bind her and is freely escaping into a world where she can discover herself and ben truly happy. It is significant that Mademoiselle Reisz is saying this because she had noticed, form the beginning, that Edna had the ability to do this, which is why she had taken a liking to Edna. It is possible that the “broken birds” that Reisz refers to is herself at a younger age. She sees hope and change in Edna.


Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Awakening Dialectical Journal Chapters 11-20

“She wondered if her husband had ever spoken to her like that before, and if she had submitted to his command. Of course she had; she remembered that she had. But she could not realize why or how she should have yielded, feeling as she then did” (42).
This quote shows Edna’s “awakening” in terms of her freedom from her husband. She begins to realize that she doesn’t want to obey her husbands every command, and she doesn’t have to. She stays outside not so much that she wants to, but that she can. The author is showing here that women have the ability to take control of their lives, but society has put them into such a state that they believe that they can’t.
“Her feet were broad and coarse. She did not strive to hide them” (45).
Mariequita is symbolic of innocence. She is a young girl who isn’t a Creole nor any person of wealth of status. She is an outsider to their society, values, and expectations. The author’s purpose of including her is to show that women’s words and actions is nurture not nature. They submit to men and try their best to fill a certain mode because they have been told all their life that they have to. Mariequita, as an outsider, has not had this lifestyle thrust upon, and therefore doesn’t have that sense of shame of hiding her flaws to seem perfect.
“Robert’s going had some way taken the brightness, the color, the meaning out of everything” (62).
This quote is an example of aphorism. The word “the” followed by a noun is repeated three times. The author employs it here to emphasize how much Robert had meant to Edna and how much of her life he had taken up. His absence is what makes Edna realize her own true feelings for him. Her passionate feelings for Robert are in contrast with her dull and tense relationship with her husband. The unfulfilling relationship that Edna has with Leonce is what causes her to seek out excitement and her awakening of her own freedom is what allows her to consider the idea of loving another man besides her husband.


Awakening Dialectical Journal Chapters 1-10

“Mr. Pontellier returned to his wife with the information that Raoul had a high fever and needed looking after. Then he lit a cigar and went and sat near the open door to smoke it.”
This quote shows the perception of gender roles in society. Mr. Pontelier sees that Raoul has a fever, but takes no action to fix it, instead waking his wife up to do it. Then he goes outside and casually smokes. This shows the authors purpose of the restriction on women because Edna is held to such a distinct and strict role that Leonce feels that it is not his job to interfere, even when the children’s health is at stake.
“And the ladies… all declared that Mr. Pontellier was the best husband in the world. Mrs. Pontellier was forced to admit that she knew of none better.”
The author includes this detail because it shows the expectations society has set out for women. If a women had a nice husband who treated her well, then she was expected to be happy and content. It was not her place to want more from her husband or for herself. As long as she was doted on, then she had no reason to complain, because it wasn’t socially acceptable to want anything else.
“If her husband did not adore her, he was a brute, deserving of death by slow torture.”
This quote characterizes Mr. Pontellier. It shows how he views Adele as the ideal woman and how he wishes Edna to behave. Not only that, but it also demonstrates the restrictions in society on both men and women. Just as a wife was expected to be happy with a nice and caring husband, the husband should not complain about a wife who is considered to fit the societal norm.


Friday, October 3, 2014

Happy Endings Sentence Style and Structure

“This is the end of the story”
Simple sentence
“The other John will emerge like a butterfly from a cocoon”
Simile
“Crying is bad for your face, everyone knows that and so does Mary, but she can’t stop.”
Compound Sentence
“Eventually they die.”
Telegraphic
“John and Mary die. John and Mary die. John and Mary die.”
Repetition
“He merely uses her body for selfish pleasure and ego gratification of a tepid kind.”
Characterization
“What happens next?”
Interrogative Sentence
“Her friends tell her that they’ve seen him in a restaurant, with another woman whose name is Madge.”
Loose Sentence
“You can see what kind of woman she is by the fact that it is not even whiskey.”
Connotation
“So much for endings. Beginnings are always more fun.”
Exposition

Thursday, October 2, 2014

The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas

The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas by Ursula Le Guin is about a seemingly perfect city filled with happiness and prosperity but that exists only due to the misery of one poor child. Through the use of contrasting setting, situational irony, and symbolism, the author develops their purpose that a happy and healthy society can only be built upon the misery of others.
                The author begins the story by describing the beautiful scenes of Omelas, the city is bright with colors, the fields lush and green, and sky is blue and bright. This is vastly different from the description of the room which the child is kept, which is dark, damp, enclosed, and dingy. The contradiction of settings is show to how one cannot exist without the other. For how horrible the conditions of the child’s prison are, the more beautiful and glorious the outside world becomes. Furthermore, the author writes “Do you believe? Do you accept the festival, the city, the joy? No? Then let me describe one more thing” after which the reader expects the author to write about another wonderful system or aspect of the city that makes it more perfect. Instead Le Guin begins to describe the child and the horribleness that it endures. The author uses this situational irony to make Omelas more believable to the reader. After so much perfection, the sudden change in description makes the reader more able to believe that this city exists because there is this horrible aspect to it, which further proves the author’s purpose that a perfect society is unachievable without the suffering of others.

                The author uses the child as the symbol of those who suffer in silence for the happiness of others. He is kept locked away and hidden so no one is reminded of their existence. Everyone knows that he is there, and that his misery is what causes their happiness. Yet if he is not in their face constantly then it is easier to justify what they do when they can only see the light it brings and not the darkness that comes with it.