Monday, September 29, 2014

Hills Like White Elephants


Ernest Hemingway’s short story Hills like White Elephants is about a young couple in Spain who must make a harsh life-changing decision before the train arrives to take them to their destination. The author uses symbolism and minimalistic dialogue to characterize the couple’s relationship of strenuous miscommunication and dishonesty.

                In the story, the man and the girl seem unable to even address the problem that is forcing them to make the decision, which reveals the problems in their relationship with communicating with one another. This inability to speak about the topic is shown symbolically, for example the girl states that the hills “look like white elephants” (475) to which the man replies that he “has never seen one” (475). The elephant symbolizes the topic which both parties know about, but neither seem able to discuss, it’s the “elephant in the room.” The girl points the “elephant” out, but the man states that he hasn’t seen one, showing that even when one party tries to bring the subject up, the other will skirt around the issue or shut it down. Furthermore, the girl’s name is mentioned once, and Hemingway names her Jig, an unusual name out of thousands of possibilities, and therefore must be symbolic. A jig is a dance, and like the name, the couple are “dancing” around the issue.

                The minimalistic and vague dialogue between the two characters characterizes their relationship as one of miscommunication. Never once is the actual problem that the two are facing stated, only vaguely hinted at in a way that can leave readers with a hunch but never sure. Hemingway purposely leaves the conversation as vague and uninformative to frustrate the reader in that same way that the couple is frustrated with each other. Every time one seems to be about to mention the problem or talk about it, the other switches the topic or completely shuts the conversation down. Without proper communication, the two will never be able to understand what the other feels and why, and without it there will always be a strain on the relationship no matter whether they decide to get on the train or not.

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

I Stand Here Ironing Literary Analysis

Tillie Olsen’s story, I Stand Here Ironing, is about a young mom reflecting on the parenting skills used on her oldest daughter and how it may have caused her damage and limited her abilities. The author uses a reflective point of view, a worrisome and confessional tone, and contrasting sentence structure to uphold how a person can be a good parent and raise a healthy child even when faced with adversity.

From the beginning of the story, it is apparent that the narrator is in the present, looking back on the past. The reflective point of view starts with the birth of the first daughter, and continues on through her difficult childhood of living with the father’s family and then later an orphanage due to the mother’s lack of money and younger children to take care of. The author uses a reflective point of view because as the mother looks back on the childhood of Emily, she uses a worrisome and panicked tone. She confesses all of the adversities and difficulties that the child had to face, and worries that it is these things that may have had a great effect on the child negatively, and that it is all her fault. Although she couldn’t always be there for her child, the fact that the mother is this burdened by what she had to do shows that she is in fact a good parent. A lesser mother would have forgotten about it and expected the child to grow up fine with those difficulties. Furthermore, the author uses contrasting sentences to how the child was able to develop healthily in the end despite these adversities. The mother’s thoughts are often in run off sentences that switches from past to present, from topic to topic, and end differently than they started. The daughter, of the few times she speaks, uses parallelism, a rigid sentence form, and in general speaks in choppy sentences. This shows how the daughter develops in contrast to the life that she was brought up in; she likes things to be neat and orderly in a world that is hectic and ever-changing. However, these are not necessarily bad qualities, and in fact will be very useful to her in life.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

Jovial


"Cathedral" Exploring the Text

1) The first-person narrator of "Cathedral" opens the story mostly talking about his wife, the blind man, and how they met. He only adds a couple tidbits about himself here and there. This shows that the narrator is a closed-off kind of person. He doesn't like to reveal a lot about himself, his thoughts and feelings, to total strangers such as the reader. This makes it more apparent how uncomfortable he is about a total stranger, who is blind into his home. He knows very little about the man, and much less about blindness, which is why he is uncomfortable with him entering the home, a place of intimacy and sanctuary, and sharing a meal and offering a bed for him, which is more signs and intimacy and communion.
2) Carver sets up the narrators meeting with the blind man as one of awkwardness and confusion. The narrator had a certain image of what the blind man would look and act like, weak and quiet with sunglasses on, but it is not what the blind man is actually like. He is loud and doesn't wear sunglasses, which makes the narrator uncomfortable and feel lost in what to do and how to act. He tries to come up with conversation, but everything he thinks to say seems to have to do with sight, so he remains silent. Their conversations and the narrators inner thoughts develop the two individuals characters as almost opposites of each other. The blind man is disables and entering a home he has never been into before, yet he seems much more comfortable, relaxed, and at ease than the narrator who seems to be left out.
3) At the beginning of the book, the narrator can't even seem to understand the concept of being blind. He doesn't understand how the man can have relationships and such without being able to see the other person. Then he sees how the blind man acts in his own home, moving around an unfamiliar environment with no trouble, eating a meal and being able to discern where everything is on the plate, and watching TV and being able to tell the difference between colored and black and white television. Seeing this makes the narrator see  past the blind man's lack of eye sight and more as a real person. He becomes comfortable enough to ask him questions about it as well. This adds complexity to the story because it shows how people can gain understanding of a foreign concept when they have been exposed to it.
5)Carver withholds specific information about the epiphany because he wants the reader to have to think about it and infer it. The author is a minimalist and believes that more can be gained by writing less. Also it means that multiple understandings and insight are being reached since there are multiple themes and topics within the story. Instead of going through them all, it is more beneficial to the reader to leave it out and let them come to their own conclusions, so that each reader gains something different from the story. The author leaves out much personal information about the narrator in order to show how restrained he is about giving out inner thoughts and feelings as well as to do show that he is an average man, with no great prior experiences and achievements that are worth mentioning, yet he can still reach understanding of a concept with which he has no knowledge.
6) The wife and the husband are far from the perfect couple. They do not talk much, and are likely to give in to temptations such as gluttony, excessive drinking, and drugs. Yet Carver does not pass judgement on the couple. He writes about these actions with little emotion or conviction, almost as if it were normal for a couple to act this way. It is to show that they are happy, but they have their own faults. I also would not judge them, because they interact how they want to, and because I do not know much about their past and their experiences, I can't judge their actions or their relationship.

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Where are You Going, Where have You Been Literary Analysis

The story Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been by Joyce Carol Oates is about a teenage girl named Connie who strives for independence from her family, but realizes only too late that she is not ready for it when she is threatened and then forced to leave her home with a deceptive man named Arnold Friend. The author’s purpose in writing the story is to illuminate the problem of how deceptive appearances can be and how they can alter ones expectations of other people and ideas. The author does this through characterization.

            In the story, the protagonist, Connie, and the antagonist, Arnold Friend, both have sides that they have from others in order to keep up a certain image. For Connie, “everything about her had two sides to it, one for home and one for anywhere that was not home.” At home, Connie is an innocent teenager who doesn't like to do chores, but when she goes out with her friends, she looks and acts in a certain way to appear as a confident, mature adult who knows about love and life. Connie’s transformation is so drastic and realistic that she seems to convince herself that she is the adult that she pretends to be, and that she is ready to leave home and be independent, which is later apparent not to be true. Furthermore, she deludes herself into believing that love as an adult is supposed to be “sweet, gentle, the way it was in movies and promised in songs.” Furthermore, when Arnold Friend first approaches Connie, he seems to be a cool, smooth-talking teenager which has a wooing effect on Connie. However, as Connie refuses Arnold’s offers to go on a ride and questions him, his whole façade begins to fade away. He loses his cool and way with words, stating “Don’t hem in on me, don’t hog, don’t crush, don’t bird dog, don’t trail me.” At this point, it is clear to both Connie and the reader that Arnold Friend’s persona is all an act and most likely is mentally unstable. Furthermore, his deception and threats towards Connie has already caused her previous notions of independence, love, and life to vanish. However, it is already too late, she has been drawn too much in by his deception, and can’t turn back.  

The Yellow Wallpaper Literary Analysis

In “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, a young woman with a mental illness is kept inside a recovery house by her husband, where she becomes infatuated with the wallpaper and slowly loses her mind. Through her treatment by her husband and her connection with the wallpaper, Gilman shows the wrongness of the oppression of women at that time as well as the mistreatment of people with mental illness through the use of setting.
                In the 19th century, the time period of the story, women were oppressed and expected to be subservient to men and their husbands. At the beginning of the story the narrator embodies this characteristic. She always listen to her husband, and never disobeys his orders even when she believes that he is wrong, instead saying things such as “What can one do?” The environment that she has lived in all her life expects her to do what her husband says without complaint, and she complies. Her husband treats her as if she were a child, not an adult, not letting her “stir without special direction” and refuses to let her do anything but sleep, believing that it will be too much for her. This treatment leads the narrator to become more mentally unstable, because the more she follows his rules the more constricted she feels and begins to express that with an unhealthy obsession with the wallpaper.
                The room that the narrator is locked it is fit for a prison, not for recuperation. The windows are barred, the bedstead chained, and the best post is marked as if someone had gnawed at it. The narrator believes that is a nursery, but that is blatant deception, it is obviously a room meant to lock people away who have mental illness. Both the constrictions on her as a woman and as someone with mental illness cause the narrator to become infatuated with the wallpaper. The wallpapers many patterns agitates the narrator, and she begins to see a woman behind it. The author uses the wallpaper as a symbol of the narrator’s illness and containment. The narrator begins to see a woman trapped behind the pattern, and so she peels off the wallpaper to free the woman, but also herself. Through the story she begins to see herself as the woman behind the paper, and in order to free herself, she must free the person within the paper.

Tuesday, September 16, 2014

The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman Responses

1) The narrator's change throughout the story is reflective of her views and relationship with the wallpaper. At first, she only comments on the ugliness of the paper. But as time goes on and she finds herself repressed with no way of expressing herself, she becomes more involved with the wallpaper. She begins to see layers of patterns in the wallpaper, and then she begins to see a woman withing the wallpaper. She begins to become one with the wallpaper, comparing herself  and relating to the woman in the paper, her creeping tendencies and how she is dormant at day but alive at night. The wallpaper represents the narrator's depression and the imaginary woman is herself and the depressions affect on her. The narrator is happy about her change. She becomes more alive, since she now has a purpose and means of expression. To her tearing off the wallpaper and freeing the woman was her own way of understanding the state she was in and how to best free herself from it. I agree with the narrator's views because how she deals with the "wallpaper" (depression), is much better than what the view was at the time for dealing with depression. John and Jennie thought it best to just deal with it or ignore it, but the narrator studies the wallpaper and looks beyond it to find the hidden patterns and then the women behind it all. This seems a much better way of dealing with someone's depression than just locking them away with nothing to do and telling them to get better.
2) Lines 38-39 state that "the windows are barred for little children, and there are rings and things in the walls." Line 234 states "How those children did tear about here! This bedstead is fairly gnawed!" This suggests that the room was not a nursery as the narrator believes. With barred windows, the room was more likely some sort of prison. The gnawed bedstead suggests that it held people who were considered mentally unwell. It develops the character of the narrator because it shows the narrators willingness to deceive herself in the hopes of trying to keep herself sane and upbeat and believing that what she is going through will actually help her. It reveals the theme of the story of how just locking people away won't help them, in fact it will make it worse, as seen by the gnawing. To truly help people with depression, one must first look at it and understand it.
4) The description of the wallpaper reflects the narrator's own agitation when looking at it. From the syntax, it is understood that the wallpaper is chaotic, with all different sorts of yellowish patterns shooting off from a central point. This reflects well with the narrators agitation because she seems to be connecting with the wallpaper. The chaos and layers of it remind her of her own condition, and it is at this point that she begins to realize, maybe subconciously, that John's treatment will not help it, and that is why she is bothered by it.

Tuesday, September 9, 2014

Symbolism in Their Eyes Were God

In Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurtson, the author uses many symbols in order to prove her main argument throughout the book. Some of the most prominent symbols are the main character, Janie's, hair, the tree that appears throughout the book, and the storm that comes at the end. Janie's hair represents independence, the tree stands for life and love, and the storm represents lack of control. At the start of the book, Janie has no control over her own life, and is forced to marry a man that she does not want to be with. This lack of control empowers her to gain control over her life, and does so by leaving her husband for a new man, and then leaving that husband for another man. With each new relationship she believes she gains more control, but when she finally meets a man with whom she is happy, Tea Cake, he gets bitten by a dog and Janie is forced to kill him. The author's main purpose in writing this book is that people will never have full control over their lives, which she shows through the symbols.

Janie's hair is symbolic of independence, which she doesn't have for the majority of the book. She leaves her first husband, Logan Killicks, for Jody Starks, in order to gain independence from her unhappy marriage. However, her second marriage is as bad as the first, as Jody controls every aspect of Janie's life, and makes her put her hair up. This is symbolic of Janie's lack of indepence and control in her life, which she left Logan to get, but never received. Throughout the book there is the appearance of trees, which Hurtson uses to represent love and life. In the beginning of the book Janie sits under a tree and goes into a dream-like state, where she sees love and marriage as interchangeable and that one will bring the other. This shows Janie's unrealistic expectations of  both love and life and that she will have control over either, which she does not. Often she realizes her mistaken thoughts she becomes determined to gain control over this aspect of her life by changing husbands. She finally does gain this independence after Jody dies and Janie moves away with Tea Cake. However, even then she doesn't have full control. At the end, a devastating storm controls, which represents that there are still things beyond Janie's control, and there always will be. After the storm, Tea Cake goes mad which forces Janie to kill him for self protection, which is her third husband lost to things beyond her control. By the end of the book, however, Janie realizes that expectations will never play out and that life cannot be controlled.