Thursday, February 12, 2015

To be or not to be soliloquy

Hamlet's soliloquy from Act 3 Scene 1 is his own struggle over whether he should live or die. Throughout the soliloquy he lists out the the reasons behind each one. He states "and by a sleep we end the heartache and the thousand natural shocks that flesh is heir to" (III.i.69-71) and later "Who would fardels bear, to grunt and sweat under a weary life, but that the dread of something after death" (III.i.84-86). In these two quotes Hamlet the two sides of his indecision, that death will bring an end to all of his earthly suffering and anguish, but he is uncertain what lies beyond death, and what awaits him could be worse than what he is facing at the moment. The way in which Hamlet thinks through this decision further blurs the distinction between madness and sanity within Hamlet. The subject of what he is debating would make one think that he is mad, yet his systematic reasoning and use of logic to debate the two sides would suggest otherwise, and perhaps suggest that Hamlet is merely acting and is aware that people are watching him. Furthermore, Hamlet's contemplation characterizes him as someone who does not act on impulse. He is someone who thinks things through before doing something. He states "Thus conscience does make cowards of us all" (III.i.91), which leads me to believe that it will be Hamlet's own conscience that will make him unable to act and make a choice when the time comes, and he will face consequences because of it.

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Fate and Free Will

1) Free will is critical in determining our path, because it is essential to what is means to be human. Our ability to think and choose freely based on our own individual experiences and personalities is what sets one person apart from another. It is because of this that each person's own path is as individual as they are. For this reason, humans are in control of their own fate or path, we have the ability to stay the course or change it at any time.
2) If one looks back on their life, it may seem that the people in it are just "actors" playing out their "roles." This ones the best friend, the other the enemy, he is the husband, she is the sister, however this is looking at it in a very narrow and single-minded manner. Who is a friend to one is an enemy to another, or a spouse, co-worker, child etc. There are too many different perspectives of one single person to fit them in a specific "role." If the world was indeed a stage, it would be too dynamic to be understood. Even though people can't be fit into roles, this doesn't mean they don't pretend to be someone they're not. Nobody is ever fully honest, with others or even with themselves, at the same time, no one is ever pretending all the time.
3) Whether revenge or suicide is justifiable would depend on the situation. In a situation, what appears to be the right or wrong thing changes depending on the context and the person themselves. One's sense of justice also bends as events come to pass, and part of that is justifying the actions of themselves as well as others, including revenge and suicide.
4) Just as justice is subjective, so is "madness." For the most part, madness in a general sense is one's loss of mental control and grip on reality. Of course, the ability to define these things and know when someone has actually lost control is hard to determine. It is context that determines how each person defines madness, and each person will see it differently. Factors of context include, society, culture, specific situation, personal experience, and others.