Tuesday, September 16, 2014

The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman Responses

1) The narrator's change throughout the story is reflective of her views and relationship with the wallpaper. At first, she only comments on the ugliness of the paper. But as time goes on and she finds herself repressed with no way of expressing herself, she becomes more involved with the wallpaper. She begins to see layers of patterns in the wallpaper, and then she begins to see a woman withing the wallpaper. She begins to become one with the wallpaper, comparing herself  and relating to the woman in the paper, her creeping tendencies and how she is dormant at day but alive at night. The wallpaper represents the narrator's depression and the imaginary woman is herself and the depressions affect on her. The narrator is happy about her change. She becomes more alive, since she now has a purpose and means of expression. To her tearing off the wallpaper and freeing the woman was her own way of understanding the state she was in and how to best free herself from it. I agree with the narrator's views because how she deals with the "wallpaper" (depression), is much better than what the view was at the time for dealing with depression. John and Jennie thought it best to just deal with it or ignore it, but the narrator studies the wallpaper and looks beyond it to find the hidden patterns and then the women behind it all. This seems a much better way of dealing with someone's depression than just locking them away with nothing to do and telling them to get better.
2) Lines 38-39 state that "the windows are barred for little children, and there are rings and things in the walls." Line 234 states "How those children did tear about here! This bedstead is fairly gnawed!" This suggests that the room was not a nursery as the narrator believes. With barred windows, the room was more likely some sort of prison. The gnawed bedstead suggests that it held people who were considered mentally unwell. It develops the character of the narrator because it shows the narrators willingness to deceive herself in the hopes of trying to keep herself sane and upbeat and believing that what she is going through will actually help her. It reveals the theme of the story of how just locking people away won't help them, in fact it will make it worse, as seen by the gnawing. To truly help people with depression, one must first look at it and understand it.
4) The description of the wallpaper reflects the narrator's own agitation when looking at it. From the syntax, it is understood that the wallpaper is chaotic, with all different sorts of yellowish patterns shooting off from a central point. This reflects well with the narrators agitation because she seems to be connecting with the wallpaper. The chaos and layers of it remind her of her own condition, and it is at this point that she begins to realize, maybe subconciously, that John's treatment will not help it, and that is why she is bothered by it.

No comments:

Post a Comment