Thursday, November 13, 2014

Are Shakespear's Messages about Gender Roles Relevant Today?

In Shakespear's play Twelfth Night, each character seems to have their own expectations of their own and the opposite gender, but as certain characters genders are unclear to other characters, it causes confusion in the characters love and attraction to which person, and those expectations of genders are mixed up. Through this identity confusion, the author is stating the message that both genders put themselves and the opposite sex in certain gender roles that not only contradict themselves but are also proven wrong.
This message is still necessary today and applies to our modern world. For all the accomplishments that have been made in reaching gender equality and the eradication of gender roles and stereotypes, they are still present in our society. In Twelfth Night the character Orsino compares men's and women's magnitude for love and passion to an appetite, stating "Alas their love may be called appetite, no motion of the liver, but the palate, that suffer surfeit, cloyment, and revolt; but mine is all as hungry as the sea, and can digest as much," (II.IV.107-111), yet earlier he states "For, boy, however we do praise ourselves, our fancies are more giddy and unfirm, more longing, wavering, sooner lost than worn, than woman's are," (II.IV.37-40). In this quote Shakespeare is showing his message about gender roles and their contradictions because Orsino contradicts himself in his own views of men and women. He claims in the second quote that men's attractions are more likely to shift from person to person, yet in the first one he claims that men are more passionate in their love for a person that women are, and even praises his own passion which he so warned about earlier on. Through this contradiction Shakespeare shows how invalid gender roles and expectations are. This message can be applied today since gender roles are still very much prevalent. The video clip "Shakespeare Gender Swap" showed that people perceived the same character doing the same actions differently when the gender was switched, often more negatively for the girls. This difference in characterization shows that society still holds certain views of each gender.
Furthermore, in Twelfth Night Viola, who is masquerading as a man named Cesario, retaliates to Orsino's comments and states "We men may say more, sweat more, but indeed our shows are more than will; for still we prove much in our vows but little in our love," (II.V.128-130). Viola's retort shows that both men and women are guilty of making assumptions based on gender, and that stereotyping leads to more stereotyping. Orsino's expectations of women makes Viola give a negative expectation of men, however this makes her no better than Orsino. This is something that often happens today. When one gender stereotypes the other, the natural response is to do the same back. This is why feminists often get a bad rap, because people state that they are for women superiority instead of equality, which is true of some but not all. A better response to gender roles is to show how and prove through actions how they are untrue, instead of creating more to belittle the other group. This will lead to less stereotyping for both sides and better understanding between all.

1 comment: