Monday, September 29, 2014

Hills Like White Elephants


Ernest Hemingway’s short story Hills like White Elephants is about a young couple in Spain who must make a harsh life-changing decision before the train arrives to take them to their destination. The author uses symbolism and minimalistic dialogue to characterize the couple’s relationship of strenuous miscommunication and dishonesty.

                In the story, the man and the girl seem unable to even address the problem that is forcing them to make the decision, which reveals the problems in their relationship with communicating with one another. This inability to speak about the topic is shown symbolically, for example the girl states that the hills “look like white elephants” (475) to which the man replies that he “has never seen one” (475). The elephant symbolizes the topic which both parties know about, but neither seem able to discuss, it’s the “elephant in the room.” The girl points the “elephant” out, but the man states that he hasn’t seen one, showing that even when one party tries to bring the subject up, the other will skirt around the issue or shut it down. Furthermore, the girl’s name is mentioned once, and Hemingway names her Jig, an unusual name out of thousands of possibilities, and therefore must be symbolic. A jig is a dance, and like the name, the couple are “dancing” around the issue.

                The minimalistic and vague dialogue between the two characters characterizes their relationship as one of miscommunication. Never once is the actual problem that the two are facing stated, only vaguely hinted at in a way that can leave readers with a hunch but never sure. Hemingway purposely leaves the conversation as vague and uninformative to frustrate the reader in that same way that the couple is frustrated with each other. Every time one seems to be about to mention the problem or talk about it, the other switches the topic or completely shuts the conversation down. Without proper communication, the two will never be able to understand what the other feels and why, and without it there will always be a strain on the relationship no matter whether they decide to get on the train or not.

1 comment: